Are SEO's Destroying SEO?

Brian Hughes
Brian Hughes Digital Marketing Director & Founder, Integrity Marketing and Consulting

Posted on March 12th 2014

Are SEO's Destroying SEO?

Sawing Tree Limb Man is Sitting OnYou’ve heard it over and over again: “SEO is dying!” From bloggers and journalists to marketers and web designers, people have been saying for years:

"SEO will never last."

"It’s all spam."

"It’s just a phase."

If you’re in the business, you’ve heard it all before. Yet after years of predictions, SEO is still standing strong. Is it possible that it’s not dying, but just evolving? It's a valid consideration, to be sure – but an even more important question might be: Are SEOs the ones actually destroying SEO?

The Changing Definition

Rand Fishkin is spot on with his Whiteboard Friday video found here. He claims “SEO is bigger than SEO”—meaning the definition seems to limit people to a strictly old school understanding of the topic. When the average blogger, journalist, marketer, or web designer hears SEO, he thinks backlinks, keywords, and site structure, period. That is essentially what SEO was from the 1990s to mid-2000s, but that is no longer the case. No longer do SEOs only pay attention to keyword data, domain data, topic analysis data, and other similar factors. The definition is changing to include a whole lot more.

Those old school tactics are still very much a part of SEO, but they provide a false picture of the present day reality. SEO has become bigger than keyword density and proper site structure. People in the industry are now looking at usage data, brand signals, offline data, social signals, and more. SEO is not just a technical, structural field anymore; it’s essentially become everything marketing is. It’s about brand positioning, social media, community building, understanding perceptions, and everything else internet marketing is.

Nowadays, in order to move up search engine rankings, SEOs must do a lot more. And if you, as an SEO, are being tasked to improve rankings with only old school tactics, you might as well be bringing a knife to a gun fight.

The Unchanging Perception

The changing definition is good news – and signals a rebirth of the term, as opposed to death – but the problem lies in the perception. If we are honest with ourselves, SEO started out with primarily black hat techniques. If you’ve been in the game long enough, you’ve probably used some yourself. That’s just the way it used to be. But with Google pushing SEOs toward white hat techniques over the years, things have changed.

SEO, done properly, is no longer spammy, manipulative, or unethical. In truth, white hat SEO is fairly difficult to differentiate from standard marketing, but the reality is that, while the definition is changing, the perception is staying the same. This is not a unique issue to SEO, but a universal problem. Perceptions are difficult to change anywhere – especially when trying to move from negative to positive.

The Term May Die, But the Industry Will Not

Fishkin brings up a good point when he says, “I think when you change the title, you change the perception.” It’s possible that the term SEO needs to die. But that doesn’t mean the industry needs to die. “You change the frame of reference, and you say, ‘I do web marketing. I help people grow their companies. I help attract visitors, and that leads to more conversions on their site,’” Fishkin goes on to say.

A really interesting infographic can be found here. It discusses all the different types of people claiming SEO is dead, what they claim, why they claim it – and why they are wrong. And they are wrong, but their number is significantly larger than that of SEOs. That’s why changing the perception is near impossible. 

In order for SEO to move beyond its shady past, SEOs need to kill the name. You should be a marketer first and an SEO second. Instead of trying to change the perception behind the title, you need to focus on changing the title and shifting the frame of reference. That gets us back to the original point that SEOs could be the ones actually destroying SEO.

Don’t Sell Yourself Short

Do yourself a favor and stop selling yourself short. You do a lot more than stuff keywords and build backlinks. You are involved in branding, PR, sales, advertising, web development, community building, social media, and more. When SEOs begin to see themselves as more than SEOs, bloggers, journalists, marketers, and web designers will start to do the same. Embrace the rebirth, not the claims of death.

You can do this in a number of practical ways. First and foremost, start giving yourself credit. Change your title and explain to clients and employers why you are doing so. Second, convince people that you need to be involved in all areas of marketing. Convince clients that you cannot do your job effectively and successfully if you don’t have your hands in PR, advertising, branding, and other areas of marketing. Third, follow the rules of white hat SEO. With the evolution of Google’s algorithms, Ken Krogue tells you to “invest in real, valuable, relevant content that your audience wants.” As all SEOs know, the new goal is to develop content for readers and not search engines. “Take the time to make it so compelling that people talk about it and share it.”

When Will SEO Die?

SEO has to die at some point, right? I suppose so, but it doesn’t appear to be going anywhere soon. As long as internet marketing exists, you will be in good shape – because you are an internet marketer. If you took a look at the infographic linked above, you noticed a section at the bottom titled “Why SEO Will Never Die.” I believe the first and third points are the most important points. Search engines want to encourage websites and blogs to post original, valuable content, so they are not going to do away with SEO. They feast off of content and would starve from the lack of it. Secondly, people want to find original content, not just advertisements. As the infographic says, “If people realized that they were looking at nothing but ads on a search engine, they would take their queries elsewhere.”

The truth of the matter is that SEOs are destroying SEO. By not standing up for the industry and continuing to conform to an increasingly negative stereotype, SEOs are selling themselves short. As Fishkin notes, change and maturation are okay. Every field matures over time. Accept the fact that SEO is evolving, not dying.

Brian Hughes

Brian Hughes

Digital Marketing Director & Founder, Integrity Marketing and Consulting

Inspirational British leader Winston Churchill once said "Attitude is a little thing that makes a big difference." I took that optimistic approach and founded Integrity Marketing & Consulting to help get brands recognized and their sites ranked highly.

I often say, "trying to accomplish the desired results from SEO without great content and branding is like trying to mix cement without water. You will not get solid long term results." But I also say this must result in more prospects and an increased bottom line to make clients happy. Accountability is key here. "A satisfied customer is the best business strategy of all." - Michael LeBoeuf

Bragging rights: #1 Search engine rankings in Google for "SEO Fort Lauderdale" and "Internet Marketing Fort Lauderdale". Search for yourself to confirm.

I consider myself an entrepreneurial-minded business owner, where I take my years of experience in SEO and branding and use that to increase online awareness of companies by getting their websites to the top of major search engines for relevant keywords. I have accomplished this for myself and my clients.

All work and no play makes Brian a dull boy. Brian enjoys life with his beautiful wife and three kids. His love of SEO and Social Media play second fiddle to his family and faith. In his spare time, you'll find Brian enjoying the bread sticks from Olive Garden, rocking out to some good hip-hop or dubstep, learning from the entrepreneurs on Shark Tank, taking in a good movie with the family, and quoting random world thought leaders. "Positive thinking will let you do everything better than negative thinking will." - Zig Ziglar

See Full Profile >


Posted on March 12th 2014 at 4:06AM

as long as people are searching there will be an SEO (search engine optimization); is changing is evolving and its trying to comprehend what is valuable for people.

It began with the basic keywords, pagerank metrics, backlinks. But as technology evolves SEO has to evolve as well; nowadays SEO produces different results for the same query. i have tried it myself between my mobile and my laptop, and reason is simply google understands that there are different needs for that particular query based on the tech i am using and the behaviour that i am engaged on that particular device, location, history of usage. and attempt to create a relevance result from its algorithms.

The question is more on the results. Do i get the results i want from the searches i am making; Lately i must say that i going in many cases in to the depths of the search Pages 2+ in order to find the actual piece of content that i am looking for.

Seo has also the component of Social these days at least in reference to G+, it takes in consideration the human factor (likes, shares, conversations, etc), however is hard to interpret the value of these conversations, is hard to consolidate the spectrum of the conversation and some times not even possible; for example same piece promoted on various networks, google has a hard time in tracking the internal content on Facebook or Linkedin and even Twitter.

Ultimatly i think SEO has the great attribute to provide a mid-long term relevance for content, queries will carry for a longer time providing relevance to your site; Social is now the viral source, exposing your content to the masses, and both aproaches are to be explored and excuted in the long road of online presence.


Brian Hughes
Posted on March 12th 2014 at 12:07PM

Thank you for your feedback Daniel. You make some great points. That's why I stated that SEO will never die but will evolve and for those that don't jump on the train will lose out.

Posted on June 25th 2014 at 12:00PM

Great article Brian!

Daniel also made some spot on points as well in his comment

SEO is certainly not dead nor is it dying. We are simply experiencing the continued "Evolution of Search". Now a days, SEO's need to be CREATIVE, strategic, socially engaged and have the ability to think outside the box inorder to succeed. The spammy SEO's will always be there trying to game the system but thats just the nature of the beast. They will come and go as we've all seen in the past.

Valuable content and a great user experience will never fade. There will always be a need for search. Cheers guys!