Connect with us:
Social Media Today on FacebookFollow SocialMedia2day on TwitterJoin SocialMediaToday LinkedIn Group

Coca-Cola & Intel: Two Social Media Approaches

I came across two interesting stories yesterday. First, Ad Age reported that Coca-Cola had issued an RFP for an agency to handle social media listening. The piece notes that, “Kerry Tressler, a Coca-Cola spokeswoman, said some 20 agencies have been involved in the selection process. She noted the company is looking to select a single agency and expects the decision will be made “fairly quickly.” She also said that roster shop 360i is among the agencies participating in the process.”

As an agency guy, and a social media guy, this is concerning. In general, I think less agencies is better than more agencies. Yes, you want best in class but at some point the task of managing a dozen agencies across your marketing department can outweigh their individual skills. I’ve been involved with a lot of big brands, for a number of different agencies, and getting them to communicate and work in harmony can be an effort, even when there roles are clearly distinct. But today, clearly distinct roles is a thing of the past. What agency doesn’t think it can handle the social media duties? Now Coca-Cola is going to add a social media monitoring agency? seems to support the notion, stating in an article on the Coca-Cola RFP: “Just as, for instance, an analytics guru who identifies a problematic page correlated with shopping cart abandonment is likely not going to be the person who fixes the usability or copy problem responsible for the abandonment, an agency that is capable of helping a client engage effectively with consumers through social media isn’t necessarily going to be the most capable of analyzing social chatter and applying the results to social and other marketing channels.”

No, they aren’t necessarily going to be able to, but they could. I don’t believe gettinganother agency is the answer, rather getting the right agency is the answer. Surely there are agencies that can use the wide variety of tools now available to monitor social media conversations, and then execute against the strategies to engage or convert or whatever is the appropriate action.  I would be concerned about the potential lag time between Agency A identifying an opportunity to engage (or more seriously, identify a potential crisis) and Agency B taking the appropriate action. I’m sure the “listening” agency is going to have ideas about how to respond that may be different from Coke’s other social media agency. In all, I see more potential problems than benefits.

The other story came from Andy Sernovitz, who looks at what Intel is up to with their social listening and engagement program. Interestingly, Intel’s Becky Brown talks about the need to “[c]entralize, consolidate and focus.” Here’s her full presentation fromBlogWell here.

Intel’s approach is inline with what I heard from Ethan McCarty, Sr. Manager, Digital and Social Strategy at IBM, in my interview with him (Part 1Part 2).  Intel, like IBM, is evolving into a Social Business.  Getting all departments and all employees on the same page. Harnessing internal experts and leveraging them to engage with consumers/customers will be essential for businesses. Those, like Intel and IBM who are moving in that direction now will have an advantage over their competitors.

Join The Conversation

  • Sep 6 Posted 5 years ago Dave Baldwin (not verified)

    I definitely think more businesses of all sizes should be adopting a listening strategy with social media. The trouble is that people still think of marketing as a noise-making activity.

  • Sep 6 Posted 5 years ago Leighh (not verified)

    I'm sure COKE is attempting to create greater efficiencies then to have their myriad of agencies all doing seperate SM monitoring efforts which is likey the case today.  While all Agencies "say" they do this work, it's actually very few who are great at it.  I think more clients should be doing what COKE is.....and as someone who worked at an "integrated" Agency, the same company who has different divisions is no less or more different than multiple companies.  Not sure what the concern is.  

Webinars On Demand

  • May 09, 2017
    With all of the technologies available to marketers today, have we lost that personal touch? Join VP of Content Marketing for ON24, Mark Bornste...
  • April 05, 2017
    In the ever-changing world of digital marketing, operational efficiency, quick turn-around times, testing and adapting to change are crucial to...