A Different View on SEO in a Post-Hummingbird World

Randy Milanovic
Randy Milanovic Principal & Author, Kayak Online Marketing

Posted on April 11th 2014

A Different View on SEO in a Post-Hummingbird World

Even though it certainly no longer qualifies as "news," a lot of the online marketing world is still grumbling, both privately and publicly, about the long-term effects of Google's Hummingbird algorithm update. More than a few businesses, not to mention website design companies, essentially think of it as the worst thing that could ever have happened… years of work literally undone overnight.

A different view of seo on a post hummingbird world.

However, all of that traffic didn't just suddenly up and disappear. More people than ever are using Google's search bar (to the tune of 2 billion+ hits per day), so where is all that traffic going? And, what conclusions can we draw from the fact that we don't often hear from the "winners" in the latest round of the top-of-the-search sweepstakes?

Who's Coming Out Ahead After Hummingbird?

I'll begin by sharing that my own firm, Kayak Online Marketing, has done very well since Hummingbird. Using HubSpot, MOZ, Positionly and other keyword analysis tools, we can see that our site currently ranks highly in a number of different areas (positions vary daily), including: (to those who would say keywords don't count any more, I'll respond with a hearty, Oh yes they do!)

  • 120+ top-three keywords in Canada (with more than 80 #1s)
  • 220+ first-page keywords in Canada
  • 65+ top-three keywords in the U.S. (which has more competition and is in our primary market)
  • 120+ first-page keywords in the U.S.

These would be great results for a company 10 times our size, and yet we do very little in the way of "technical" search engine optimization. In fact, over the past year, we have implemented a strict 90% policy, meaning that we pay the vast majority of attention to putting together original, timely, and unique pieces of content (like this post) that speak to our most important target audiences.

The only challenge with this approach is that it requires a lot more upfront research and content crafting. And, I guess you could say that it requires some of our time and energy to keep up with comments and feedback on each piece of content that we post. But, that keeps us well away from the position that many of our peers found themselves in after Hummingbird – wondering where traffic went, complaining about things we can’t control, and looking for the next shortcut or easy way to game the system.

If this sounds like I'm being overly harsh, understand that I'm not trying to condemn any of my peers or competitors, just to point out that it's always better to give your most important customers what they're looking for, rather than trying to rig your website (and eventually need to counter that rigging as well) to make it more appealing to search spiders.

That's been true since the first days of online marketing, but the current state of search technology is unmasking a lot of the individuals and organizations who tried to get away from that. In other words, the answers are more obvious than they've ever been.

How to Look at SEO – and Hummingbird – Now

Besides companies that have smart content building and engagement strategies, do you know who else never complains about Google algorithm updates? The answer is actual searchers. - RM

In other words, the folks who aren't dependent on Google for marketing aren’t just supportive of what the world's largest search engine is doing, but actively supportive. They love that the company is doing all it can to take out spammy, redundant, and low-quality links. Neither they nor Google has anything against your business, they just want it to be easier to find the information and resources they are actually looking for when they type a query into the search box, rather than keyword-heavy pages that waste their time.

The way to look at SEO, and specifically search optimization in a post-Hummingbird world, isn't that it's getting harder, but that things are getting better. In order to come out on top, a business or marketer needs to be relevant, timely, and engaging. That's something we should all be shooting for all along.

 

Randy Milanovic

Randy Milanovic

Principal & Author, Kayak Online Marketing

Randy is author of 2 books: Findability: Why Search Engine Optimization is Dying + 21 New Rules of Content Marketing, and Building a Better Business Website. He is the Prinicipal of Kayak Online Marketing.

See Full Profile >

Comments

MCCCODE
Posted on April 10th 2014 at 9:29PM

Randy all good points.

As a side note i have been hearing many business saying that they will step down from SEO since the amount of work to clean up their act is inmense, and rightfully so.

SEO was working on a ecosystem of backlinks (the more the merrier you may even say), that suddenly change, i know a company that invested over 10 years on SEO marketing applying the better practices of the day (or BH before hummingbird), while getting over 50k backlinks from this long term activities, their research showed that over 30% of their backlinks where defined as harmfull and 50% of those (estimated) were unreachable owners to help the cleaning process.

So not saying not to clean your act, the opposite, but you may consider rebranding as an option, and not a easy decission of course.

 

 

Randy Milanovic
Posted on April 10th 2014 at 10:42PM

Agreed. There is indeed a time to start fresh. Some websites have no choice. The good news is that recovery can be swift when done by the book.

Szymon Slowik
Posted on April 11th 2014 at 9:23AM

I totally agree that post-hummingbird internet will be better (I write about future because in many non-English networks it's still not making noticeable impact - in Poland for example). Good SEO will base on psychology more than only on technical optimization. That's good sign for marketers who are creative,  care more about users than just rankings pumped by massive link building.

Randy Milanovic
Posted on April 12th 2014 at 12:06AM

Agreed Szymon... link building is now link earning.