This Isn't Margaritaville - So Lose the Parrot Head

Susan Emerick
Susan Emerick Founder & CEO, Brands Rising, LLC

Posted on February 24th 2014

This Isn't Margaritaville - So Lose the Parrot Head

Many brands have given their employees permission to use social media, published a social media policy, and offered training on the use of social venues. But that level of support leaves a lot of potential value on the table.

Many brands avoid empowering their employees in social media because they do not want to dis-intermediate the marketing team from customers, or they do not want employees creating brand assets that the brand does not own. Some brands fear that employees in social media could damage brand reputation or violate regulations and create liability for the brand. Some brands just do not know how to begin.

Regardless of how a brand feels about its employees in social media, nearly every brand today has employees who are active in social media and employees who talk about their brand in social media. Those employees engage in social media for a wide range of reasons. In many cases, employees get into social media because their partners and customers demand it.

While almost every brand today can find employees using social media to discuss their products, services, working conditions, and so on, the brands that achieve the most value deploy corporate resources and guidance to empower their employees in social media.

Simply asking employees to parrot brand-generated messages through their personal social media may help the brand to gain small amounts of reach or engagement, but it is not a sustainable strategy for engaging audiences and developing relationships online. It is easy to do, so a lot of brands do it; however, that approach fails to respect the relationships employees and their audiences, so it does nothing to help employees create a differentiated and effective presence online. Specifically, when people simply repeat brand-generated messages, they lose the ability to attract people like me, thereby diminishing their ability to build trust and advocacy online, or worse irritating their network and causing abandonment.

Here's a hilarious example of the effect of parroting messaging featured by Conan O'Brien:

See what I mean?

All joking aside, this kind of parroting can do huge damage to your brand. Not only is irritating your followers, it's likely driving them away in droves.

A preliminary study that I've been working on, with my colleagues in IBM Research Watson Lab, has found that more than 50% of the 230,430 followers of a certain branded social account is also following more than one of the company's branded or employees accounts. Given this, there is a risk of creating more spam than value for our constituents, if parroting messaging and distributing through multiple accounts continues. Resulting in the opposite of creating value.

My team has coined the phrase "Ecko Gecko" to describe the phenomenon. We've created guidance to help our employees understand what negative affects parroting messages has when they simply copy and paste the same message and share it across multiple accounts. There is significant risk in damaging brand reputation.

Leading brands monitor social media and use social media analytics to observe and evaluate the effectiveness of their employee's who are engaged in social on behalf of their companies. It's scary what you might find. Especially when it comes to the practice of copying and pasting the same message over and over then distributing via social accounts, both branded and employee accounts. Are you monitoring in this way?

There is an important opportunity here, a teaching moment. Don't let it paralyze your efforts, use the insights to create new education and training to course correct. Share the findings from your analysis and provide clear, concrete incentives for behavior modification. If you share examples of what not to do, backed by quantifiable and substantiating evidence based on data which demonstrates the negative impact these actions have, such as:

  • driving “un-follows"
  • encouraging “opt-outs”
  • causing “removals from lists”, (just to name a few)

Who can argue or ignore that?

For more on how to help your employees improve engagement rather than just broadcasting & parroting messages, read Chapter 2: "Help Your People Do Well", of The Most Powerful Brand on Earth

Susan Emerick

Susan Emerick

Founder & CEO, Brands Rising, LLC

Susan Emerick is the Founder of Brands Rising, LLC providing strategic advisory services in social media analytics, influencer engagement & employee advocacy. Prior to pursuing an entrepreneurial path, she lead a number of IBM's transformational social business & digital strategy initiatives which reshaped the way the global brand engaged in the internet era.

Emerick has pioneered and scaled Employee Advocacy programs (Digital IBMer, IBM Select & IBM Voices), fueled by social media analytics that helping 400,000+ employees become more targeted and efficient with their social media engagement. She recently co-authored her first book with Chris Boudreaux called: The Most Powerful Brand On Earth: How to Transform Teams, Empower Employees, Integrate Partners and Mobilize Customers to Beat the Competition in Digital and Social Media. She serves on the Social Media Today Advisory Board and WOMMA Research & Measurement Council.


See Full Profile >