Pinterest VS. Stumbleupon - For Page Views

OsakaSaul
Saul Fleischman Founder of RiteTag.com, OsakaBentures

Posted on March 22nd 2012

Pinterest VS. Stumbleupon - For Page Views

Pinterest is all the rage, as of this writing...

People are motivated to visit blogs from Pinterest by one thing: image quality --

Let's remember, every action in liking, re-pinning and sharing in Pinterest is visually-driven.  Recipes, kittens in coffee cups, hot infographics, and inebriated people removing themselves from the gene pool - along with brilliant photographic and video work will get seen, shared (read: lifted and repinned to others' boards) and make you the cat's meow in Pinterest

Seldom-discussed fact: Pinterest is hardly new.  Private beta invites went out in the beginning of March, 2010

I think its just a matter of how long I've been using Pinterest and perhaps the OsakaSaul name that people have "seen around" that has caused me to collect likes, repins and a slew of followers within Pinterest.  I have been kicking their tires for nearly two years, and while they're gotten flashy, I would love to see them be more thoughtful to the user in their user experience.  My ideas for just the most obvious Pinterest UX improvements:

  • Close windows after we've liked/shared
  • let us multi-share with boxes to tick, rather than having us repeat steps
  • provide us with us more condensed view options - so we can get more done with a lot less scrolling

For me, words are my strength.  Article titles drive traffic from many sources, and terms, or "key words" within the body of posts draws natural search traffic.  A couple Google Analytics screenshots should speak volumes.  For Referral Page Views, StumbleUpon is still doing it for me, with 1,095 pageviews in the last 30 days (just 4 new articles published in that time), and Pinterest, where I have had an account and boards for about two years, does not even make the top 25.  Also, note the 1.19 page visits (means some people see other pages after the one they came to see, once on my blog) and an average stay of 58 seconds:

Where do I find Pinterest within Google Analytics?  39th place - seven visits/30 days.

My blog sure does repel visitors from Pinterest; look at that bounce rate!

Seven visits, thanks to my seven boards in Pinterest and dozens of images, most of which lead to OsakaBentures.com.  While the Time on site of 10:13 and 3.57 average pages viewed would look glorious, I'm not buying it:

  1. the sample is too small - just seven visits to my blog from Pinterest, so, I'm guessing that one or more people left their computer on and the browser showing my blog and did other things for an hour or so - before closing the browser or going elsewhere on the internet;
  2. my own wife would not listen to me for 10:13 at a time (or read 3.57 of my writing) - even when we were still dating, and she still felt compelled to pretend to take interest in what I had to say.

If you, too, are not using breathtaking images, infographics, or showcasing the People of Walmart in original and shocking ways...

Learn to build a presence in StumbleUpon

  1. Follow people you know, to start, but understand that it will take some time to understand how they are going to use StumbleUpon.  I get better and better at looking at a Stumbler’s number of likes, the recency of likes and what they like – and decide if the Stumbler is going to appreciate what I share to them, perhaps “SU-like” on occasion, and maybe not share tons of odd stuff to me.
  2. Every couple days, from Profile > Connections > Visitors, from the pull-down menu, see who you don’t already know (they could be people you are already connected to who simply looked at your likes most recently), and see what their stats tell you.  What do they like? How often, and when was the last time they shared content? Follow (or don't) wisely; you can only follow 500 people in StumbleUpon.
  3. Stumble-review your own post, and also go through your blog circle, etc. and SU-like your supporting bloggers’ latest posts.The first review on a page is the StumbleUpon "Discovery Review" - and counts the most for StumbleUpon SEOStumbleUpon allows you to add as many tags as you like, but actually uses the first five you provide. These, multiplied by the number of likes you have on the page, once reviewed, increase the likelihood that your page will appear “randomly” before Stumblers who are Stumbling their followed topics.
  4. For reviews on your own posts/pages - or any that you want to be sure get in front of many Stumblers' eyes - test your tags in the StumbleUpon “Explore Box,” which suggests acceptable StumbleUpon topics from words and phrases that you input.

If your content is not particularly visually dynamic and you are seeing far better results, please share what you are doing differently.

OsakaSaul

Saul Fleischman

Founder of RiteTag.com, OsakaBentures

Social web apps, community management, marketing too. Working with internet startups in user experience as well as community-building projects, and supporting emerging social web applications creators by helping them engage and grow their online communities.

See Full Profile >

Comments

I did the Discovery Review for the "How to Pinterest for Bloggers" webinar in StumbleUpon, and am sharing that.  Some of you (Dino included) are connected to http://www.stumbleupon.com/stumbler/osakasaul and if so, if you see your Shares (lower left, from your own profile) and use the pull down in middle of page from there to see "received shares," you'll find that.  Please upmark and share to your sharable people.


Also, even if we're not connected, just see http://www.stumbleupon.com/stumbler/osakasaul and see my likes.  Dino's post is my most recent, so whether you follow me (I need a day or two to follow-back), my latest like is on top, just like and share-on, if you would.  Getting many eyes on this will be a cake-walk if a few of us do just that.
Happy to help!


People should find this piece, my own article on Pinterest VS Stumbleupon for bloggers to be a nice prep for Dino's webinar.  


Let me know, also, if I can help spread the word for the webinar in other ways, Dino et al!