Are You a Bad Parent if You Say No to Social Media for Your Kids?

memktgservices
Mandy Edwards Founder/Chief Social Media Strategist, ME Marketing Services

Posted on August 4th 2014

Are You a Bad Parent if You Say No to Social Media for Your Kids?

Telling your child 'no' to social media doesn’t make you a bad parent… or does it?

As parents, we are encountering things we never thought imaginable as kids. Wouldn’t it have been cool to have a conversation in pictures sent via your phone?? Or never have mom or dad get lost because you had a GPS in your car? How about as a teenager, you wouldn’t have to worry about your boyfriend or girlfriend’s dad picking up the phone when you called?

In this day and age, kids don’t know what all of that is like. I remember when we got cable. And a microwave. And a VCR. I remember my first CD (Ace of Base’s “The Sign”). Who knows what "firsts" kids these days will experience.

With all these “firsts” comes the hard part - parenting kids through them. Yes, when I got my first CD and CD player I wanted to listen to it 24/7 but mom said no. Now when kids get their first tablets/iPod Touch/smartphones, we as parents have to be even MORE careful and dutiful about saying no. Especially when it comes to social media.

Did you know the age minimum for the major social media networks is 13? Now, how many kids under 13 years old do you know on Facebook? How about Instagram? SnapChat? I know more than I care to admit. I understand that every parent is different. Some are more open to letting their kids try things out, some are more reserved. I’m going to say this once and move on because I know I could ignite a huge debate, but by allowing your under 13 year old to have a social media account shows them it’s okay to lie. You have to put in their birthdate to activate an account and if you put their real birthdate you would not be allowed to open an account. Showing your child it’s okay to fudge their age to get something is not right. There, I said it. Let’s move on.

I have an almost 10 year old who will be starting 4th grade in the fall. She has friends on Kik, SnapChat, Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram. They are all 9 years old. This Spring, we allowed her to get an iPod Touch with the money she had saved up. We set up a few rules - I got to set everything up so I could place the proper restrictions and passwords, it always goes on the kitchen counter at night and her dad and I get to look through her phone at anytime for any reason.  I also told her upfront that social media was not a conversation to be had until she was 13.

If she had asked for me to set up social media accounts, I would have said no. She would have thrown that pre-tween fit and said I was a bad mom, but you know what? I would have loved it. Sometimes doing the right thing as a parent means being the bad parent. Saying no to social media for your child is only for their benefit. Here are 5 reasons why -

No social media-As if!

1. You are protecting them from strangers. Even with all the internet-nanny programs and account restrictions you can have, that still wouldn't stop a predator from seeking out your child.  Unfortunately my husband, who is a state prosecuting attorney, has had cases of this.

2. You are protecting them from cyber-bullying. Being a tween/teen is hard enough offline, they don’t need the burden of the online bullying to hurt their still-building self-esteem.

3. They post content without thinking, especially pictures. Some of this content may hurt them (or haunt them) on down the road and/or hurt a friend’s feelings. Under 13 year olds are not mature enough to understand the long-term ramifications of posting hurtful content.

4. They have their whole life to use social media. Kids are only kids for so long. Let them be that. Let 9 year olds ride around on bikes. Let 10 year old boys play baseball or football. Encourage your kids to be active and social - without an electronic device.

5. Not using social media to communicate at this age allows them to be taught the proper way to carry a conversation with others. I know teens who could use a lesson in that. With a generation that is texting the person next to them instead of talking or SnapChatting pictures instead of enjoying an event, the lesson of how to hold a proper conversation is being lost. Not to mention their writing - but that’s another topic for another day.

Telling your kids they cannot have social media accounts is not a bad thing and does not make you a bad parent. Let them wait until they are old enough to handle it and when they are, they will appreciate it more. Good things come to those who wait, right?

What’s your take on this topic? Share with me below!

memktgservices

Mandy Edwards

Founder/Chief Social Media Strategist, ME Marketing Services

Mandy Edwards is the owner of ME Marketing Services, a social marketing company that provides social media consulting, coaching and management to businesses around the globe.

ME Marketing Services was founded in 2011 after 12+ successful years in the sales and marketing industry.  Previous work experience includes newspaper advertising and event management for 3 different newspapers and marketing for her local Chick-fil-A.

Mandy was recently listed as one of the Statesboro Herald's Top 20 Under 40 for 2013 and has been mentioned in Forbes, Crain's Chicago Business and the Huffington Post.

 

See Full Profile >

Comments

TiggerRD
Posted on August 7th 2014 at 7:39PM

My kids are on board with the no social network sites until they are 13.  And I used the same reason you outlined above, I would have to lie if I signed them up for an account.  I didn't want to compromise my integrity and I want to let them know that they can count on the truth from me, so I should be able to count on it from them.  They are also well aware of many examples of cyberbullying and inappropriate content posted by their peers.  It is hard, but critical, for parents to keep a dialog going with their kids about their values and monitoring and guiding kids as they begin to navigate social media is an important area where kids should not be left to their own curiosity or the guidance of their peers. It does suck (from their point of view) to be left out, but the way my kids see it when watching total strangers when we are out and about, is that they see an individual or a small group huddled  around an electronic, but not really laughing or enjoying the present time with the folks that are gathered right next to them and they think that sucks for the electronics-addicted folks even more.

memktgservices
Posted on August 16th 2014 at 10:51AM

I agree! In fact something that bothers me is that one of my closest friend's oldest children (who's 12) had a teacher this week wanted all of the students to create a Facebook profile for a caveman as a part of their assignment. They are all under 13. Fortunately the parents have been open with them enough that they all spoke up and told the their teacher they were not allowed to be on Facebook because they weren't old enough. It seems we need to be educating adults now as well.