I am deeply interested in wikis, and business oriented ones in particular, in fact was considering doing a fairly detailed comparative study, so I got really excited seeing on twitter that Tom Raftery posted an Enterprise wiki review. Too bad it's not a review; it's a rant that lacks any methodology or real comparison.
He goes at length describing the installation nightmare:
The setup of the Confluence wiki was far from straightforward. It took two of us the best part of a day to simply install it. Remember that as I was doing this for it@cork, this was not billable time. I was installing it on my own server and because Confluence requires TomCat as its webserver it had to run on a separate port to Apache. This meant several people couldn't view it in their organisations.
Sounds to me like a case of bad platform choice. Now, I am by far not as technically inclined as Tom is, and am biased: I won't touch anything that needs to be installed. That's what Software as a Service is for. Which, incidentally is an available option for Confluence, so how Tom got into comparing "hard-to-install" Confluence with hosted PBwiki and Socialtext is beyond me - it's an apples-to-oranges comparison. And there's not much of a comparison either... here's all he has to say about two other products:
By the way, I did also try out DekiWiki and Twiki but I ruled them out quite early on.
That's not a very detailed review, if you ask me. DekiWiki is downloaded about 3000 times a day (!), so some people must like it... even though their acquisition of SocialText was just an April 1 joke.
Joke apart, a word on picking the right tool for the right job: perhaps you don't even need an "enterprise class" wiki for a conference. The official Oracle Wiki is based on Wetpaint, a decidedly consumer and community-focused platform.
My personal takeaway from this to me is to look at PBWiki: when I last checked it out, it was a baby-wiki for some reason popular in geek circles; apparently it has grown up. I'm not sure I will get to do the wiki review I've been planning, but in the meantime if Tom decides to write a real one, I am looking forward to reading it.
Link to original post